MLB Handicapping: Betting on September Baseball
by Nicholas Tolomeo - 8/25/2011


Betting on September and October regular season baseball is an entirely different animal than the first five months of the baseball season. Contenders have their playoff roster finalized with all their deadline deals in the books and pretenders are making their annual September call ups as position battles take place for 2012.
With most of the divisional races already determined and a good majority of the teams in the league already eliminated, baseball games after September could seem rather meaningless until the playoffs arrive, unless, of course, you are an MLB handicapper. Then you know while everyone else is busy focusing their entire bankroll on football, there is plenty of value to exploit in baseball.
Here is a list of traditionally strong teams to keep an eye on this September and teams that have traditionally thrown in the towel by this point in the season.
Heating Up
Chicago Cubs
  The Cubs traditionally wilt under the spotlight and  pressure. Remove the spotlight and pressure and the struggling Cubs all of a  sudden become a tough out in September. Their strong play in the final few  weeks of the season won former interim manager and current Manager Mike Quade  his job. The Cubs went 18-10 after Sept. 1 last season, an incredible record  for a team that had been 20 games under .500 heading into the month. It was  their fourth consecutive winning September. Since 2007 the Cubs are 63-47 after  Sept. 1.
Philadelphia  Phillies
  When the weather turns cold in Philadelphia, the Phillies  get hot. Since 2006 the Phils are an incredible 91-51 in regular season games  after Sept. 1. They won a remarkable 22 of 29 games last season during that  time span. Even with the odds the Phillies are laying they are as solid of a  bet that there is at this point in the year.
San Francisco  Giants
  Like the Phillies, the Giants have made a habit of  heading into the baseball playoffs with a head of steam. Last season they went  16-12 in regular season games in September and October. They have enjoyed three  consecutive winning Septembers although nowhere near at the kind of clip  Philadelphia has won this late in the year. The Giants are 45-38 after Sept. 1  during the regular season dating back to 2008.
Cooling Off
Pittsburgh Pirates
  What the Pittsburgh Pirates do in September is the equivalent  of taking your jacket off in the North Pole and diving in a bucket of ice. Last  season the Pirates went 13-16 after Sept. 1. That was their best record during that  span since 2006. In that time the Pirates are an awful 41-71 after Sept. 1.  Good thing Steelers season has already started at that point so nobody in the  city realizes how much worse their baseball team gets once September rolls  around.
Washington  Nationals
  The last three seasons the Nationals have entered  September, at least 20 games under .500. And they have managed to dig a deeper hole  during September and October. The Nationals go into full out experimental mode  during this month, trying out new pitchers and position players and it has  worked out to the tune of a 31-49 record during September and October since  2006.
Most Recent Baseball Handicapping
- 6 MLB Coaches Who Were Better Players Than Skippers
- 65 MLB Financial Statistics for 2025
- Five MLB Players Who Went from MVP Talks to Out of the League
- MLB Prospects Who Were Hyped as the Next Big Thing and Flopped
- Best Bets for Teams to Make the MLB Playoffs: Yes or No Props
- 5 Underperforming MLB Pitchers who Dominated in the Postseason
- Six MLB One Season Wonders Who Fell Off Fast
- Top 6 Forgotten MLB Postseason Clutch Performances
- MLB Season Awards with Updated Odds and Predictions
- Chicago Cubs vs Houston Astros Weekend Series Predictions with Odds and Analysis
