Docs Website

54 Years Strong! A Trusted Leader In Sports Picks, Best Bets and Predictions Since 1971.

Main Menu

NFL Careers That Were Defined by a Single Super Bowl

by Jeremy Block - 1/30/2026

NFL careers that were defined by a single Super Bowl David Tyree

Some NFL players are defined by a single Super Bowl performance that shapes their entire career. Don’t get it twisted, these aren’t players with Hall of Fame stats or years of record-shattering seasons, but they’ve got a ring to their name, and that one game is all it takes to write their legacy.

Whether they were the hero or just stepped up in crunch time, these players’ careers will forever be tied to that one unforgettable Super Bowl performance. Let’s check out six NFL careers that will always be defined by a single Super Bowl moment.

Doc’s Sports offers NFL expert picks for every game on our NFL predictions page.

Nick Foles

There’s always that one quarterback who steps in, shuts down the haters, and defies the odds when no one expects it. That was Nick Foles for the Philadelphia Eagles in Super Bowl LII.

In the 2017-2018 season, Foles was the backup to Carson Wentz, the Eagles' prized possession. That is, until Wentz tore his ACL in Week 14, putting him out for the rest of the season. Enter Foles: a guy with 0 starts and just 10 completions on 14 attempts. Being thrown into the starting role, just two weeks before the playoffs, he did the unthinkable—leading the Eagles to its first-ever Super Bowl title. Let that sink in: a backup QB, tossed into the starting role due to injury, with no one expecting anything, and he becoming an instant legend.

Facing off against the Patriots in the big game, Foles threw for 373 yards, three touchdowns, and even caught a touchdown himself on the iconic Philly Special. Foles quickly became the new sheriff in town. That Super Bowl performance? It made him a hero, even earning him Super Bowl MVP honors.

Most of Foles’ career was spent as a backup, but on that night, he outperformed Tom Brady. In the blink of an eye, Nick Foles went from backup to Super Bowl MVP, and that one game easily defined his entire career.

Malcolm Butler

Keeping it on the Patriots, cornerback Malcolm Butler was a solid addition to New England’s secondary. Coming into the league as an undrafted free agent in 2014, the Pats rolled the dice, and it definitely got its money’s worth. Butler had a decent season, recording 14 solo tackles with zero interceptions—but then came Super Bowl XLIX.

With the Seahawks on the 1-yard line and a touchdown away from stealing the game with just a minute left, Butler made his moment. He jumped in front of Russell Wilson’s pass and snagged the interception, sealing the win for the Patriots.

Butler’s career was solid, but that pick? That was everything. He never quite lived up to the shutdown corner expectations that analysts and fans had for him, and his years after that moment didn’t match the same level of fame. But for those few seconds in Super Bowl XLIX, he became the most important player on the field.

Doug Williams

The Washington Commanders haven’t exactly racked up a lot of accomplishments as a franchise, but the little they’ve got? That’s mostly thanks to Doug Williams and his unforgettable Super Bowl XXII performance.

Williams had a pretty average postseason leading up to the big game in 1987, with just three touchdown passes for 326 yards over two games. But then everything changed. Facing off against John Elway and the Denver Broncos, no one, and I mean no one, believed in Williams or the Redskins. Even Washington fans had their doubts.

But Williams came out hungry, torching the Broncos for 340 yards and four touchdowns, completing 18-of-29 passes. The final result? A blowout 42-10 win, with Williams earning Super Bowl MVP honors. On top of that, he set two records: he became the first African American quarterback to win a Super Bowl and tied the record for most passing touchdowns in a single Super Bowl at the time.

But after the legendary Super Bowl run, though? Williams’ career never quite lived up to that one night. He had some solid seasons, sure, but nothing ever matched his performance in that game. In a league dominated by legends like Joe Montana and John Elway, Doug Williams will always be defined by Super Bowl XXII, and no matter how many seasons passed, that’s all anyone needed to remember. 

Larry Brown

When most people think of the Cowboys in the 1990s, names like Troy Aikman, Emmitt Smith, and Deion Sanders come to mind. But for Super Bowl XXX, it was Larry Brown’s time to shine.

Going into the postseason, Brown was already having a solid season, racking up 43 solo tackles and six interceptions. Still, he wasn’t quite in the conversation of stars—until this game, that is.

With the Cowboys leading and the Steelers trying to catch up, Brown snagged two interceptions to help seal the 27-17 win. And when you make two picks in the Super Bowl, it doesn’t matter what you did in the regular season. Larry Brown’s name is forever tied to that game, and his performance earned him Super Bowl MVP honors, turning him from a role player into an NFL legend.

But despite winning Super Bowl MVP, Brown’s career never quite kept that same level of production many expected after that game. His post-Super Bowl years were decent, but his career remained somewhat stagnant after that.

Joe Namath

This may be a sore spot for Jets fans, but it’s one that has to be on this list: Joe Namath and his infamous Super Bowl III win.

Look, in the grand scheme of things, Joe Namath’s career wasn’t all that stellar, despite the Hall of Fame honor. His numbers aren’t through-the-roof oppressive, and he had more bad seasons than good ones. But none of that mattered because Super Bowl III put him into the history books forever.

In that game, Namath completed 17 of 28 passes for 206 yards with zero interceptions, against one of the best defenses of that era—the Baltimore Colts. Sure, his stats weren’t glamorous, but he played smart and stepped up when it mattered most. His performance was clutch, and he even earned Super Bowl MVP honors.

Now, while Namath did have some solid seasons after his 1969 Super Bowl run, the truth is, his career will always be defined as “the guy who brought the Jets its only Super Bowl.” Without that win, Namath would probably be remembered as just another quarterback with a few mentionable games at best. But because of that win, he’s the guy who took down the greatest team defenses ever—and that will forever be his story.

David Tyree

While the players on this list had their careers defined by one Super Bowl performance, there are even players whose careers were defined by one play in a Super Bowl. Enter David Tyree and his unforgettable helmet catch in Super Bowl XLII.

The Giants were trailing the Patriots with just 1:12 left in the game. With the blitz coming, Eli Manning threw up a Hail Mary, and Tyree, surrounded by three defenders, somehow made the impossible grab—pinning the ball against his helmet to keep the drive alive. That catch wasn’t just a career-defining moment; it was also the play that changed everything for the Giants, allowing them to pull off one of the most shocking upsets in NFL history.

After that, Tyree’s career went nearly radio silent. After sitting out the next season with a knee injury, Tyree played just one more year in 2009 with the Ravens, only appearing in 10 games before retiring. Even with the quick and abrupt ending to his football career, Tyree’s name will forever be linked to that catch, which earned him a place in NFL history.

Get NFL picks on every single game, or if you want our very best bets by the experts, sign up for your free $60 account with a guarantee.

Most Recent Super Bowl Betting

One E-mail A Week Is All You Need!
Our weekly newsletter is loaded with exclusive free picks,insight and advice from our expert handicappers