College Basketball Handicapping: Returning Starters 
by Trevor Whenham - 11/17/2009
![]()

One of the reliable long-term indicators of  betting success early in the college basketball season is the number of  returning starters a team has. A team returning all of their starters is going  to have an advantage over a team returning two or fewer starters most of the  time in the opening weeks of the season before the new starters can get  comfortable and settle in. There are obviously exceptions to that rule, but for  the most part it is effective. There are about 25 teams in the country that  have five starters from last year coming back. Here's a look at 10 of the more interesting  teams in that enviable situation:
  
  Kansas- Kansas is different than a lot of teams here because they have five  returning starters, but they also have a freshman, Xavier Henry, who may be  better than those starters. Kansas has almost as much talent as they had in  2008 when they won it all, and they are a way deeper team this time around.  Experience is going to pay off in a big way here.
  
  Ohio  State - The Buckeyes are without a top sixth man now that B.J. Mullens  has gone pro, but everyone else is back, and they have one of the league's top  players in Evan Turner. The weak spot is at point guard - they'd rather not  have to rely on a returning starter there. Still, with Purdue losing their  point guard for the long term, Ohio State has the deepest and most experienced  roster in the league.
  
  Butler - This team won 26 games last year and they return all of their  starters, so the Horizon League title is definitely Butler's to lose. Even  better, four of those five starters were freshmen or sophomores last year, so  we can expect a step forward from them. Butler has been an elite mid-major team  for a long time, and that's not going to change now.
  
  Arkansas - After going 12-2 in non-conference play last year, Arkansas  won just two of 16 SEC games. The players that are returning will benefit from  the experience of that crash to earth, but it remains to be seen if they are  good enough to make any meaningful gains. Unlike some teams on this list  success will depend more upon the new players than the returners.
  
  Bethune-Cookman - This team is coming off their first winning season in  Division I. They were third in the MEAC, and with a young roster that is now  more experienced and ready for the grind of the season they could take a step  forward from there. This isn't a team that scores a lot, but improved offense  and continued defensive strength could see this team playing for a MEAC title.
  
  Western Carolina - This team not only returns all of their starters, but  they are an old team - they have five returning seniors and four juniors. They  tied for the lead of their weak division in the Southern Conference last year,  and expectations are high for them to take a big step forward from that this  year. Their depth, experience, and backcourt are enough to make this a real  contender now that Davidson doesn't have Stephen Curry.
  
  Tennessee - Last year Bruce Pearl lost all sorts of players and had a  team that was too small and lacked shooters, yet they won 21 games, won their  division, and lost the conference championship game. The team that earned that  unlikely success is entirely back this year. Last year what they did was a  surprise. This year an impressive season will be no surprise.
  
  New Mexico State - Times have been tough since Reggie Theus left New  Mexico State, but this could be the year that they turn an important corner.  The biggest thing this team has going for it is the backcourt, and guards can  certainly benefit from extra experience. They were third in the WAC last year  with just one returning starter. That conference is wide open this year, so the  Aggies could be significantly better this year.
  
  Portland - Gonzaga has finally shown some chinks in their armor, so  there has to be some hope for other teams in the WCC. The Pilots return all  five starters, and the most upperclassmen in the conference. This team shot  like crazy last year - especially from three-point range. Experience won't hurt  that. Experience is going to let this team be a real contender - even if  Gonzaga turns out to still be Gonzaga.
  
  Oregon - The Ducks were coming off consecutive NCAA Tournament  appearances, so their 8-23 showing last year was an unmitigated disaster. Now  Ernie Kent is fighting for his job, and he needs a big season. I don't like his  chances. The core is back, but that's not a big thing when that core clearly  wasn't ready for primetime. The Ducks will be better, but it's hard to imagine  them being significantly better.
Most Recent College Basketball Handicapping
- 2025 Arkansas Razorbacks Basketball Predictions and Odds to Win National Championship
 - 3-for-1 anniversary college basketball picks special offer
 - Non Conference College Basketball Betting Loophole
 - 2025 Iowa State Cyclones Basketball Predictions and Odds to Win National Championship
 - 2025 Illinois Fighting Illini Basketball Predictions and Odds to Win National Championship
 - 2025 Alabama Crimson Tide Basketball Predictions and Odds to Win National Championship
 - 2025 Tennessee Volunteers Basketball Predictions and Odds to Win National Championship
 - 2025 Gonzaga Bulldogs Basketball Predictions and Odds to Win National Championship
 - 2025 Auburn Tigers Basketball Predictions and Odds to Win National Championship
 - 2025 Michigan State Spartans Basketball Predictions and Odds to Win National Championship
 
