7 College Football Teams That Won A Big Game, Then Blew It

College football has produced its fair share of upsets over the years, but one big win doesn’t always lead to sustained success. Whether it was a struggling school pulling off a big upset or a contender getting a signature rivalry win, sometimes one win can propel a team to a great season. However, other times it has the opposite effect. These seven college football teams pulled off a big win that seemingly defined their season but ended up being the last gasp at success before a disappointing ending.
Doc’s Sports offers college football expert picks for every game on our college football predictions page.
#1 2024 Alabama: Beat Georgia, Lost to Vanderbilt
The Alabama Crimson Tide entered the 2024 season with national championship aspirations despite the retirement of legendary coach Nick Saban. They opened the year with four straight victories and climbed to the top of the rankings with a 41-34 win over No. 2 Georgia in late September. Quarterback Jalen Milroe threw for 374 yards, ran for 117 yards, and had two touchdowns through the air and two on the ground. The victory propelled Alabama to the top of the AP Poll, and they looked like their usual selves with new coach Kalen DeBoer.
However, Alabama’s championship aspirations took a massive hit when they traveled to Nashville to take on Vanderbilt as 23.5-point favorites. Vanderbilt had never beaten a top-five opponent in 60 attempts and had lost to Alabama 23 straight times, a drought that dated back to 1984. Vanderbilt controlled the clock with more than 42 minutes of possession en route to a 40-35 upset, handing Alabama their first loss of the season.
The Vanderbilt defeat was just the beginning of the end for the Crimson Tide, as they went from top of the rankings down to No. 17 by the season’s end. They lost to Tennessee two weeks after Vanderbilt, were demolished 24-3 by an unranked Oklahoma side in late November, and capped off their season with a 19-13 loss against Michigan in the ReliaQuest Bowl on New Year’s Eve. There are few other teams that went from on top of the world to a flaming disaster like the 2024 Alabama Crimson Tide.
#2 2007 Stanford: Won as 41-Point Underdogs, Finished 4-8
The 2007 Stanford Cardinal pulled off one of the biggest upsets in college football history when they traveled to face No. 2 USC in early October. Stanford was off to a miserable 1-3 start under first-year coach Jim Harbaugh and entered their date with USC as 41-point underdogs. USC had won 35 consecutive home games and was expected to cruise to another victory.
The Cardinal trailed 23-17 late in the fourth quarter, but quarterback Tavita Pritchard orchestrated a miraculous game-winning drive. Stanford converted a fourth-and-20 to keep the drive alive, and Pritchard found Mark Bradford for a 10-yard touchdown on fourth-and-goal with 49 seconds remaining. The 24-23 victory snapped USC’s incredible home winning streak and handed the Trojans their first defeat of the season.
However, Stanford’s historic victory did not translate into sustained success. The Cardinal lost four of their next five games, including a 33-17 defeat to Washington and a loss against Notre Dame, who finished 3-9. Stanford finished 4-8 on the year despite beating a USC squad that went 11-2 and won the Rose Bowl.
#3 1985 UTEP: Stunned National Champion, Finished 1-10
The 1985 UTEP Miners pulled off one of the most improbable upsets in college football history. UTEP entered their October 26th matchup against No. 7 BYU with an 0-6 record as a 35-point underdog against the reigning national champions. BYU had won 24 consecutive conference games, 14 in a row against UTEP, and this was expected to be a one-sided affair. The Miners had other plans.
UTEP shocked the world with a 23-16 victory, highlighted by a 100-yard pick six from defensive back Danny Taylor. The Miners forced four interceptions in the victory and held a BYU offense that had been averaging more than 500 yards per game in check.
Unfortunately, this historic victory was the only bright spot in a miserable season. UTEP finished the year with an abysmal 1-10 record, with their BYU upset being the only win of the season. The Miners proved they could compete with the national champions for one afternoon but went on to lose every other game. The UTEP defeat prevented BYU from defending their crown, as they went on to lose in the Citrus Bowl to finish 11-3.
#4 2017 Syracuse: Stunned No. 2 Clemson, Didn’t Win Again
The Syracuse Orange were in the middle of another mediocre season after starting 3-3 before defending national champion Clemson came to town in October 2017. The undefeated Tigers were 24-point favorites on the road in Upstate New York, but things did not go as expected.
Syracuse pulled off a stunning 27-24 upset in front of their home crowd, holding a lethal Clemson offense off the scoreboard in the fourth quarter. Syracuse never trailed in the matchup, with quarterback Eric Dungey throwing for 278 yards and three touchdowns. They didn’t need turnovers to create the upset, as Clemson was responsible with the football but was held to 2-for-11 on third down while Kelly Bryant threw a season-low 116 passing yards. Syracuse looked as though they had what it took to turn the season around, but that was not the case.
Syracuse was a big underdog in their following matchup against No. 8 Miami, and only lost by a touchdown, but then went on to lose four more in a row against unranked opponents to finish 4-8 on the season. They allowed 64 points against Wake Forest at home just four weeks after beating Clemson and lost with an embarrassing 56-10 scoreline against Louisville the following week. The last win of the season came against Clemson, which won its other 11 regular season games. The Tigers would go on to lose in the College Football Playoff, while Syracuse could do nothing but reminisce about their final win of the season.
#5 2018 Purdue: Crushed No. 2 Ohio State, Finished 6-7
The 2018 Purdue Boilermakers had quite the roller coaster of a season. They opened up the year with three straight defeats against unranked opposition, then upset No. 23 Boston College for their first win of the season. That led to a four-game win streak, capped off by a stunning upset against the previously undefeated No. 2 ranked Ohio State Buckeyes. They came into that matchup as 12-point underdogs but handed them an embarrassing 49-20 defeat. Freshman receiver Rondale Moore put up 170 receiving yards with two touchdowns, while D.J. Knox added 128 yards on the ground. It turned out to be the only defeat of the season for Ohio State, but Purdue was unable to capitalize on the momentum.
They lost by double digits to Michigan State the following week but then upset No. 16 Iowa 38-36 two weeks after. Purdue finished the regular season 6-6 with a perfect 3-0 record against ranked opposition, before losing 63-14 against Auburn in the Music City Bowl. It looked as though Purdue was going to make history after their stunning upset, but they never cracked the Top 25 and finished with a losing record.
#6 2021 Stanford: Stunned No. 3 Oregon, Lost Final Seven Games
The 2021 Stanford Cardinal pulled off one of the biggest upsets in the modern era when they hosted undefeated No. 3 Oregon on October 2. Oregon looked unstoppable with four straight wins, including a pair of blowouts and a road win over Ohio State. They had their sights set on a national championship, but Stanford did not go down without a fight. The Cardinal trailed 24-17 late in the fourth when quarterback Tanner McKee orchestrated an 87-yard touchdown drive that included a touchdown pass to Elijah Higgins as time expired. Stanford went on to win 31-24, handing Oregon its first defeat while improving to 3-2 with a pair of ranked wins.
However, that thrilling victory proved to be Stanford’s final win of the season. They immediately fell 28-10 to Arizona State the following week and lost seven straight to close out the year 3-9. That included a 52-7 loss to Utah, a 35-14 loss to Oregon State, a 41-11 loss to California, and a 45-14 loss to Notre Dame to wrap up the year. Stanford started the season with high hopes and was able to exceed those expectations, but their victory over Oregon turned out to be a lone bright spot in a disappointing campaign.
#7 2021 Michigan State: Upset Michigan, Lost to Purdue
Michigan State was off to one of their best starts in program history with seven straight wins to kick off the 2021 season to climb to No. 8 in the AP Poll. That included big wins against No. 24 Miami, Nebraska, and Illinois, and it looked as though Michigan State could be on their way to the playoffs. They then made it eight straight wins with a 37-33 victory over No. 6 Michigan, climbing up to No. 3 in the country. They stormed back from a 30-14 deficit late in the third quarter, and they were right in the national championship conversation.
However, their championship dreams came crashing down just one week later. Michigan State traveled to face an unranked Purdue team that already had three losses on the year. They allowed Purdue quarterback Aidan O’Connell to throw for 536 yards and suffered their first defeat of the season by a 40-29 scoreline. Michigan State was sent plummeting down the rankings, and their dreams of reaching the playoffs were squashed when they lost 56-7 to Ohio State two weeks later. They recovered to finish 11-2 on the season with a Peach Bowl victory, but their inability to capitalize on the Michigan upset remains one of the biggest missed opportunities from the 2021 season.
Get college football picks on every single game, or if you want our very best bets by the experts, sign up for your free $60 account with a guarantee.
Most Recent College Football Handicapping
- 7 College Football Teams That Won A Big Game, Then Blew It
- NCAA Football Predictions: Week 12 Opening Line Report and Picks
- NCAA Football Predictions: Week 10 Opening Line Report and Picks
- 7 College Football Seasons Ruined by One Bad Game
- NCAA Football Predictions: Week 9 Opening Line Report and Picks
- NCAA Football Predictions: Week 8 Opening Line Report and Picks
- NCAA Football Predictions: Week 7 Opening Line Report and Picks
- NCAA Football Predictions: Week 6 Opening Line Report and Picks
- NCAA Football Predictions: Week 5 Opening Line Report and Picks
- NCAA Football Predictions: Week 4 Opening Line Report and Picks
