Docs Website

54 Years Strong! A Trusted Leader In Sports Picks, Best Bets and Predictions Since 1971.

Main Menu

One Signature Play That Defined 6 NFL Careers Forever

by Jeremy Block - 8/27/2026

Signature play that defined NFL careers forever Malcolm Butler

The NFL has a funny way of boiling a career down to one moment. A guy can put in 10+ years, stack up the stats, and still get remembered for a single play that either turned him into a legend or followed him around for the rest of his life.

Most of the guys here got remembered for the best thing they ever did on a field, and one got stuck with the worst. Agree with it or not, that one moment is what sticks. Here are six players whose whole NFL career came down to a single snap.

Doc’s Sports offers NFL expert picks for every game on our NFL predictions page.

Jackie Smith (1979)

Wide open in the back of the end zone during Super Bowl XIII, Jackie Smith did the one thing a Hall of Fame tight end is never supposed to do: drop the ball with the game on the line. A perfect pass from quarterback Roger Staubach slipped right through his hands in the biggest game of his life, and Dallas was forced to settle for a field goal in a game it would go on to lose to the Steelers by four points.

The gut-wrenching part of it all? Smith was 38 years old and in his final season, no longer the guy who racked up five Pro Bowls in his prime. He'd put together a solid 16-year career with over 7,000 receiving yards, but this was the moment that stuck with fans.

Who would have thought that after 16 seasons in the NFL and a spot in the Hall of Fame, fans across the world would still only care about the five seconds Jackie Smith dropped the bag in his final game? 

Kevin Dyson (2000)

January 2000, Titans down a point to the Bills in a wild card game. Wide receiver Kevin Dyson got an opportunity nobody saw coming, including himself. With a teammate going down injured on the return unit, Tennessee had to make an audible, and Dyson got subbed in for a kickoff return that would take his career to a whole new level.

Buffalo kicks it off, Frank Wycheck fields it, and for some reason flings a lateral toss across the field to Dyson, who catches it in stride with a good set of blockers out front. From there it was a clean coast, going 75 yards to the house, game over. Talk about a movie ending, right?

They named it the Music City Miracle, and it's been one of the greatest things to happen to Tennessee Titans football in franchise history. What makes it stranger is that Dyson's resume before that was nothing too crazy. He was a first-round pick in 1998, taken ahead of Randy Moss of all people, and had just over 1,000 receiving yards combined in his first three seasons, but injuries wore him down fast enough that he was out of the league before he hit 30.

Steve Gleason (2006)

Who would've thought an undersized backup safety, mostly known for playing special teams, would give an entire city one of its most emotional moments in sports history? Steve Gleason did just that. First home game in the Superdome after Hurricane Katrina, 90 seconds in, Gleason came flying off the edge on a punt and got a hand on it. A teammate fell on the loose ball in the end zone for a Saints touchdown, and the place completely lost it.

Now, even though Gleason was practically a nobody for his entire seven-year career, of the four blocked punts he had, this one springboarded him into Saints history and eventually got its own statue outside the stadium, which tells you everything about what it meant for the city of New Orleans.

Years later, Gleason was diagnosed with ALS, but people still know him as “the guy who blocked the punt for a touchdown right after Hurricane Katrina.” Ask anyone in New Orleans, and that block is where the legend starts.

Mark Sanchez (2012)

Thanksgiving night 2012, Jets and Patriots, and quarterback Mark Sanchez decided to invent a brand new way to fumble: the Butt Fumble. On a busted play, Sanchez tried to scramble in the pocket and head up the middle only to meet his offensive lineman Brandon Moore's butt, coughed the ball up, and the Patriots scooped it and took it back for a touchdown. Still to this day, it might be the single most replayed blooper in NFL history.

The unfair part of it all is that Sanchez was genuinely having a good season. He took the Jets to back-to-back AFC Championship games in his first two seasons, winning multiple road playoff games, and threw for over 2,800 yards that season. For a stretch there, he looked like the answer the Jets needed for decades.

None of that is the first thing anyone brings up. Say Mark Sanchez to a football fan and the Butt Fumble comes up before the success in the playoffs ever does, if it comes up at all. It's the cruelest kind of career summary, but it's also the first and only of its kind, a quarterback running into his own lineman's butt and fumbling the ball.

Odell Beckham Jr. (2014)

Some rookies need a whole season to get noticed. Odell Beckham Jr. needed one throw from Eli Manning against the Cowboys on Sunday Night Football. Manning let it rip deep down the right sideline, Beckham got held by the defense and still was able to stretch all the way out and haul in the touchdown with three fingers on his right hand while falling backward. Look, the ball had no business being caught, and right after the instant replay showed what happened in slow motion, news stations had this clip running for weeks after.

That grab turned his name into a staple for the best wide receiver conversations, whether he belonged there or not. Unlike most of the players on this list, Beckham Jr. was already on track to being a superstar at the time, going for 91 catches, 1,305 yards, and 12 touchdowns in only 12 games that rookie season, which is absurd for a player who missed the first month.

While Beckham Jr. put together a genuinely good career, made a few Pro Bowls, and eventually won a Super Bowl with the Rams, he picked up a reputation as a bit of a hothead along the way. None of that matters when his name comes up. The first thing anyone pulls up, every single time, is that ridiculous one-handed touchdown catch.

Malcolm Butler (2015)

Nobody had a clue who Malcolm Butler was until the final seconds of Super Bowl XLIX. The Seattle Seahawks sat a yard away from the winning touchdown with tailback Marshawn Lynch in the backfield, one of the best short-yardage runners in the league at the time, but Russell Wilson decided to make a throw, and what a mistake that was.

Butler, an undrafted rookie, jumped the slant route and picked off Wilson at the goal line to hand New England the title. The entire football world lost its mind. That interception flipped Butler from being an average joe cornerback into a name no one forgets with heartbreaking plays like this.

Bring up Malcolm Butler to any football fan and the goal-line pick is the first and usually only thing they mention. He suited up for hundreds of games for multiple teams over the years, but his entire seven-year career comes down to one read, one jump on the ball, and one of the most shocking endings the Super Bowl has ever seen.

Get NFL picks on every single game, or if you want our very best bets by the experts, sign up for your free $60 account with a guarantee.

Most Recent NFL Handicapping

One E-mail A Week Is All You Need!
Our weekly newsletter is loaded with exclusive free picks,insight and advice from our expert handicappers