6 Strange Equipment Obsessions That Cost NFL Players Thousands in Fines

Uniform fines are about as boring as NFL discipline gets, usually a few thousand bucks for socks pulled too low or a jersey left untucked. Most players pay up, fix the problem and move on.
A handful of players treated the dress code like a personal challenge to push the limits as far as they could. Six of them kept wearing what they wanted no matter how many fine letters showed up in the mail, and a couple of those bills got pretty ridiculous. Let's take a look at a few players who racked thousands in equipment fines.
Doc’s Sports offers NFL expert picks for every game on our NFL predictions page.
Jim McMahon, Chicago Bears (1985)
The 1985 Bears had plenty of characters, and their quarterback might have been the biggest one. Jim McMahon wore an Adidas headband all season without hearing a peep from the league office. Then he wore it in a playoff game against the Giants, and commissioner Pete Rozelle suddenly fined him $5,000 since Adidas wasn’t a league sponsor. Five grand doesn’t sound like much today, but McMahon has admitted it was a lot of money for him back then.
Rather than back down, he showed up to the NFC Championship with “Rozelle” scribbled across his headband. The commissioner got such a kick out of it that he sent McMahon a letter, though he never gave the money back.
For the Super Bowl, McMahon switched to headbands promoting charities, figuring the league would look ridiculous fining him for those. He even warmed up in the Adidas headband before the game, with the referee chasing him around telling him he couldn’t wear it, then swapped it out right before kickoff. The Bears went on to crush the Patriots 46-10, and McMahon’s feud with the league over a strip of cloth across his head became one of the most memorable sideshows that season.
Brian Urlacher, Chicago Bears (2007)
Endorsement money usually goes straight into a player’s pocket, but one Bears linebacker’s deal ended up costing him six figures. Brian Urlacher sat down at Super Bowl media day wearing a Vitaminwater hat, with a bottle of the drink sitting right next to him. Urlacher had an endorsement deal with the company. The NFL? They had a deal with Gatorade, a massive competitor.
Urlacher had the hat on for about three minutes before the Bears’ PR staff got him to take it off. All told, the stunt cost him $100,000. A regular-season violation would have run him $10,000, but the league charges ten times as much during Super Bowl week because of all the exposure. Do the math, and that’s roughly $33,000 a minute for what was, at the time, the largest non-suspension fine in league history.
Vitaminwater got its money’s worth, since the fine made national headlines when it came out a couple of months later. As for Urlacher, the Colts beat his Bears in the Super Bowl, so it wasn’t a great week for him all around.
Brandon Marshall, Chicago Bears (2013)
Plenty of players have used their cleats to make a statement, and the league rarely lets it slide. Brandon Marshall’s statement was impossible to miss, with lime green cleats and pink laces on a Thursday night against the Giants in 2013. He wore them to raise awareness for mental health, a cause close to him personally, and his foundation even had a couple of downtown Chicago buildings lit up green that night.
The league had already warned him he’d be fined and at one point threatened to keep him off the field altogether. Marshall wore them anyway, the Bears won 27-21, and the fine letter showed up a few days later for $10,500. He matched it with a donation to his foundation and auctioned off the cleats for charity, so the cause came out way ahead of the league.
Cam Heyward, Pittsburgh Steelers (2015)
Some fines are about sponsors, and some are about something a lot more personal. Cam Heyward wrote “Iron Head” across his eye black to honor his father, former NFL running back Craig “Ironhead” Heyward, who died of cancer in 2006. The league hit him with a $5,787 fine for displaying a personal message.
Heyward doubled down the next week in a win over the Cardinals, putting him on the hook for an $11,576 fine as a repeat offender. The timing made the league look even worse, since former Bengals lineman Devon Still had written “Leah Strong” on his eye black for his daughter the season before and never got fined.
Heyward eventually sat down with the league, agreed to honor his dad in other ways and saw both fines reduced.
Odell Beckham Jr., New York Giants and Cleveland Browns (2016-2019)
If the NFL handed out an award for uniform violations, one receiver would need a whole shelf for his. Odell Beckham Jr. got hit with an $18,000 fine for wearing cleats honoring late broadcaster Craig Sager, even though he planned to auction them off for cancer research.
A trade to Cleveland didn’t change a thing. Beckham played his first game as a Brown wearing a Richard Mille watch worth close to $200,000, which is a lot of money to have strapped to a wrist with linebackers flying around. A few weeks later, the league fined him $14,037 because his pants didn’t cover his knees.
The league wasn’t done, either. In a Week 9 game against Denver that same season, officials told Beckham to swap out his Joker-themed custom cleats at halftime or stay on the bench. He made the switch, but between the cleats, the watch and the pants, Beckham had made it pretty clear that no fine was going to change how he dressed for work.
Antonio Brown, Oakland Raiders (2019)
A decade-old helmet ended up costing one receiver a lot more than a fine. Antonio Brown had worn the same Schutt Air Advantage helmet his entire career, and the league banned it for being more than 10 years old and no longer certified. The company had stopped making it back in 2011, but Brown refused to trade it in for a newer helmet.
He filed two grievances to keep it and lost both. To make matters worse, he’d already shown up to camp with frostbitten feet from a cryotherapy session in the wrong shoes, so the Raiders were having a long summer before the helmet fight even heated up.
The standoff kept him away from the team, and he was fined $40,000 for missing a practice and another $13,950 for skipping a walkthrough. Brown finally settled on a new Xenith helmet, but the damage was done. After another fine voided about $29 million in guaranteed money, the Raiders cut him before he played a single regular-season game, and the Patriots scooped him up the same day.
Get NFL picks on every single game, or if you want our very best bets by the experts, sign up for your free $60 account with a guarantee.
Most Recent NFL Handicapping
- NFL Week 11 Line Movements with Point Spread Analysis
- Best NFL Teaser Bets Week 11: Basic Strategy Teasers Advice
- 6 Strange Equipment Obsessions That Cost NFL Players Thousands in Fines
- NFL Betting Predictions: Week 11 Opening Line Report and Best Bets
- NFL Week 10 Line Movements with Point Spread Analysis
- Best NFL Teaser Bets Week 10: Basic Strategy Teasers Advice
- NFL Betting Predictions: Week 10 Opening Line Report and Best Bets
- Keenan Allen Trade from Indianapolis Colts to San Francisco 49ers: Betting Impact
- Jacksonville Jaguars Trade with Philadelphia Eagles for DT Jordan Davis: Betting Impact
- 6 NFL Draft Picks Who Refused to Sign and Forced Their Way Out
